DR19-67 KANAHELE & KANAHELE

STATUS

A hearing and agenda was held on October 24-25 and 28, 2019 starting at 9:30 am in Hilo, Hawai`i at the Grand Naniloa Resort, Crown Room located at 93 Banyan Drive.

A hearing and agenda to adopt a decision and order was held on October 31, 2019 starting at 9:00 am via video-conference from Hilo, Lihu`e, Kahului, and Honolulu.  The Commission deferred action on the matter until a tentative meeting date scheduled for November 20-21, 2019.

The Commission issued its Decision and Order in this docket on November 29, 2019, Denying to Petition for lack of jurisdiction.  The Decision and Order can be viewed below under the heading Notices and Orders.

On November 29, 2019 Petitioners (Kanahele and Kanahele) served notice of an appeal to the Hawai`i Supreme Court.

BACKGROUND

PETITION OF KU`ULEI HIGASHI KANAHELE & AHIENA KANAHELE, Individuals, for a Declaratory Order Concerning the invalid classification of the de facto and improper industrial use precinct on approximately 525 acres of State Land Use Conservation District lands located in Mauna Kea and Hilo, County of Hawaii, Tax Map Key No: 4-4-015:009 (por.) (filed 9/3/19)

PETITIONER

Petition for Declaratory Order

Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Petition (10/15/2019)

Petitioner’s Submission of Referenced Materials; Appendices “A”-“B” & COS (10/28/19)

COUNTY

County of Hawai`i Notice of Non- Appearance (9/16/19)

OFFICE OF PLANNING

Office of Planning’s Comments on Petition for Declaratory Order; LUC Docket No. DR19-67; Ku`ulei Higashi Kanahele and Ahiena Kanahele TMK No. 4-4-015:009 (por) (10/18/19)

 

PUBLIC CORRESPONDENCE

University of Hawai`i at Hilo’s  (UHH) Response to Petition for Declaratory Order (9-17-19)

Comments 10/11/2019

MaryLu Kelley, Billy Boy

Comments 10/12/2019

Robert Soares, Laura Arcibal

Comments 10/13/2019

Anna Louise Fontaine, Jade Young, Kathy Vierra, Mona Trenae-Maynard, Laura Arcibal

Comments 10/16/2019

Cindy Freitas, Gary Hooser, Alexander McNicoll, William Freitas

Comments 10/17/2019

William Freitas

State Department of Land and Natural Resources Response to Petition (10/15/2019)

DLNR Exhibit A:  BLNR Decision and Order for Mauna Kea CDUA

DLNR Exhibit B:  Ku`ulei Kanahele Testimony

DLNR Exhibit C:  Partial Transcript for BLNR Mauna Kea CDUA

TMT International Observatory LLC Response to Petition (10/17/19)

State Office of Planning Comments on Petition (10/18/2019)

Lehua Kaulukukui 10/21/2019

Comments on October 20, 2019

Hanalei Fergerstrom

Comments on October 21, 2019

Marc Lefebvre, Katherine Roseguo, Amanda Niles, Josie Kojima, Cheryl Burghardt, Annette Reyes, David Shizuma, Mele Look, Suzie Garrett, Kim Falinski, Garid Faria, Stephen Paulmier, Thayne Currie, Simon Bouchard, Momi Ventura, Ronald Fujiyoshi, Kirra Swenerton, Warnice Hanamaikai, DeWaine Tollefsrud, Sandra Kirkpatrick, Ru Carley, Kelsey Baker, Patti Freeman, Ravi Grover, Anna Louise Fontaine, Michelle Cabalse, JoAnn Tsark, Lisa Lehuanani Chang, Raphiell Nolin, Stephanie Ross, Normand Dufresne, Hope Fa-Kaji, Miles Greenberg, P. Tearson, Clarence Ching, Janet Graham, Michael Zhang, Mele McPherson, Eric Tielemans

Comments on October 22, 2019

Jane Young, Sean Nagamatsu, Joan Heller, Janice Jong, Michelle Sandell, Eric Takasugi, Corrina Marcelino, Jane Perry, Christina Manzano-King, Olivia Pasciuta, Sierra Club Hawai`i Island Group – Deborah Ward, Karen Luke, Kapela Eli, Sheridan Noelani Enomoto, Mahina Oshie, Miles Yoshioka, Tiara Na’puti, Mike Maddux, Maxine Kahaulelio, Katherine Roseguo, Eddie Werner, Momi Wheeler, Audrey Allencastre, Erik Meade, Deissery Ann Medeiros, Daniel Kalani Wassman, Kenneth Wagner, Joseph Kualii Lindsey Camara, Ashley Kaono

Comments on October 23, 2019

Marisa Plemer, Yvonne Geesey, Kevin Landers, Puaʻena Ahn, Serafina Gajate, Alihilani Katoa, Uala Mills,  Charles-Michael K. Victorino, Ariel Murphy, James Stone JR, Alyssa-Marie Kau, Carmen Hulu Lindsey

Comments on October 24, 2019

Shelley Muneoka, Joseph Kohn, Dexter Ke’eaumoku Ka’iama, Jessica Waiaʻu, Kapua Silva, Donn Mende

Comments on October 25, 2019

Prana Mandoe, Edward Ayau, Pomaikalani Bertelmann

Comments on October 28, 2019

Kamana Kapele

Comments on October 31, 2019

Michael Formby

NOTICES & ORDERS

Order Denying Petition for Declaratory Order (11/29/10)